Visit Pavilion's column >>

PAVILIONHome Page

Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 16; Links Seeded: 253
Member Since: 2/2008Last Seen: 11/06/2009

A real solution to the FL and MI problem

Live Poll

Who Did You Call?

  • Obama Campaign - Reached a Human Being
    43%
  • Obama Campaign - Didn't Reach a Human
    7%
  • Democratic National Committee - Reached a Human
    14%
  • Democratic National Committee - Didn't Reach Human
    21%
  • Democracy For Amer - Reached a Human
    0%
  • Democracy for Amer - Didn't reach Human
    7%
  • Other
    7%

Total Votes: 14

Live Poll

Who Did You Email

  • My Friends and Family
    18%
  • Democracy For America
    0%
  • MoveOn.Org
    18%
  • Obama Campaign
    18%
  • Democratic National Committee
    27%
  • News Organization
    9%
  • Blogged It Somewhere Else
    9%

Total Votes: 11

advertisement

While the democratic national party leadership wrings its hands over FL and MI and allows the media to have a field day with the whole situation, there is a real solution that is fair to all parties.

Ask the Carter Center to come in and mediate a solution between all involved parties. That's what the Carter Center does, well its one of the things the Carter Center does. And it does it very well too.

The Carter Center has been in operation for 25 years now. Founded in 1982 by former Democratic President, Jimmy Carter and his wife Rosalynn Carter, the Carter Center helps resolve conflict in the world. Its mission statement calls for the prevention and resolution of conflict as well as the enhancement of democracy.

The Carter Center lists dozens of elections that it has been involved in. From small local elections in China, to elections in South American Countries and the Mideast, former President Jimmy Carter and his team have developed a reputation for fairness. The Carter Center Democracy Program claims to have assisted 69 elections in 27 countries. They will only become involved in an election if they are invited.

The Democracy Program describes its duties on the Center Website:
___________________________________

Before an election, Carter Center observers meet with election officials and party leaders to discuss electoral procedures. Sometimes they mediate election disputes and help all sides to agree on election rules. During this phase, assessments are made of the voter registration process, voter education efforts, and the fairness of the campaign "field of play."

On election day, observers are dispatched with systematic survey forms to urban and rural areas to witness preparations at poll openings, voting, and vote counting to try to determine whether the vote was secret and fair at the sites they visited. In addition to talking with polling site officials and party witnesses, observers talk with citizens and note any complaints.

After polls close, delegates observe the counting of votes and the delivery of ballot boxes. Then, the entire delegation meets to discuss its observations and issue a statement of findings as a group. If necessary, qualified high-level observers can serve as mediators to facilitate the peaceful transfer of power.
___________________________________

Barack Obama has called America to a new kind of politics. He has called for a politics of bringing people together and solving our problems by sitting down at the table with all involved parties and working out solutions. The problems of super delegates and the FL, MI primaries could derail the Democratic nomination process. If there were ever a problem in politics that demanded all sides to come together and find an equitable and peaceful solution this is it.

The Carter Center specializes in mediating and observing election processes. But, they will not become involved unless invited. The leadership of Democratic National Party seems to be doing nothing but wringing its hands over the whole mess. Barack Obama's campaign is focused on uniting this country and solving problems by consensus. That is why he has so much appeal with so many people.

We (constituents of the Democratic Party) have a vested interest in moving beyond the division of this primary season – we've every right and responsibility to take charge of our own party. So, I've a few suggestions:

On Monday morning:

1. Call Barack Obama's campaign headquarters. Request that they ask the leadership of the Democratic National Party to invite the Carter Center for the purpose of mediating a solution to the FL and MI primary problem. Obama Campaign Headquarters: (866) 675-2008 - once the voice system starts in press 6 to speak with a volunteer.

2. Call The Democratic National Party headquarters. Request that they invite the Carter Center into this process for purposes of mediating a solution to the FL and MI primary problem. The phone number is: (202) 863-8000

3. Call Democracy For America. Request that they call on the Democratic National Party to invite the Carter Center into this process for purposes of mediating a solution to the FL and MI primary process. The phone number is: (802) 651-3200

4. Use the weekend to email all your friends and relatives about this plan. Link them to this article. Let's draft the Carter Center for an equitable solution to this problem and live up to the hope of Barack Obama's campaign – that America can move beyond the divisive politics of the past.

5. Use this weekend to link this article to every website you can think of who would have an honest interest in a fair and equitable solution to this problem.

6. If anyone knows the phone number for MoveOn.org (3.3 million members we can tap into) or any other phone numbers we can flood on Monday morning, post them here. Let's draft the Carter Center and bring this problem to a fair solution for all.

7. Call Nancy Pelosi's office. She came out in the press this morning asking Clinton and Obama to settle down. The number to her office is: (202) 225-4965 Tell her, inviting the Carter Center in to mediate a solution the FL and MI mess is something EVERY democrat would respect.

8. One person emailed me contact information for the Carter Center - it follows: Carter Center is (404) 420-5100 or (800) 550-3560, website is http://www.cartercenter.org , and email address is carterweb@emory.edu

___________________________

Edit - 03/13/2008

Hello Everyone:

Thank you for making phone calls, sending emails and contributing to this article with your comments. In addition to all the public comments - there have been private communications as well. What I'd like to say here - is that some things may unfold within the next few days. So, I'm going to ask all of you (who have been working so hard and been so enthusiastic about the Carter Center option) to stand down for a bit. At this point I believe, very deeply, that we need to take a wait and see attitude.

I know this must be coming out of left-field for you - but I'm going to ask you to trust what I am saying. I didn't start this whole thing easily. It is not in my character to get this deeply involved in politics, but something just kept at me about this situation and so I took action, when I never have before. I really want to thank all of you who have made phone calls, sent emails, and gotten involved in this effort. Your time has not been wasted. We worked together and lived up to Barack Obama's expectations of us:

I'm asking you to believe, not just in my ability to bring about real change in Washington ... I'm asking you to believe in yours.

We believed in our ability, and I honestly feel it made a difference. Thank you all for everything you have done and for all of your enthusiasm.

To summarize: There are some things that may unfold within the next few days. So, I'm going to ask all of you to stand down from pursuing the Carter Center option for a bit. At this point I believe, very deeply, that we need to take a wait and see attitude.

In Peace:

Pavilion

  • 17 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

Published to:

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
11
{"commentId":1554610,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Let's do the work - get the word out to everyone we can think of - and Monday morning start drafting the Carter Center to mediate a solution.

{"commentId":1554610,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#1 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 10:16 AM EST
Reply
{"commentId":1554938,"authorDomain":"acidreflux"}

Why no reference to calling Hillary's HQ as well, hmmm? Your trolling is weak, grasshopper.

{"commentId":1554938,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"acidreflux"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#2 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 12:04 PM EST
{"commentId":1554958,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Feel free to post the number - this is an open thread and you're free to comment with substance. Substance would be an actual phone number.

{"commentId":1554958,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 3 votes
#2.1 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 12:09 PM EST
{"commentId":1555539,"authorDomain":"wharrison55"}

Why on earth would one suppose that Democratic Party members call on the supposedly good offices of Jimmy Carter to handle something that is entirely a party matter? Had they adopted the sensible position and merely penalized MI and FL for jumping the gun by cutting the number of delegates across the board those two states could contribute as did the GOP they wouldn't be facing this trainwreck. The Democratic Party made this mess for itself, they can clean it up.

{"commentId":1555539,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"wharrison55"}
  • 1 vote
#2.2 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 2:53 PM EST
{"commentId":1555766,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Well you're right about one thing - the Democratic Party made this mess. And now, the democratic constituency has two choices.

1. Sit back and assume the DNC leadership (who created the mess) will clean it up. I'm not guessing that will happen. Howard Dean seems quite unable (or unwilling) to bring all affected parties together and come to an equitable solution.

2. Or - the democratic constituency can do something absolutely unheard of - they could get involved.

On a personal level - I'm going for getting involved. I'm going to pick up the phone on Monday and make some phone calls. I'm going to try and convince as many people as I can that we should all be demanding that the Democratic party invite the Carter Center into mediate and monitor a solution.

It's risky. I'm just one tiny little voice in the middle of nowhere USA. But, maybe, just maybe, if others act with me, our voices will affect some change.

As Obama has said:

But we know how much farther we have to go. We know it takes more than one night – or even one election – to overcome decades of money and the influence; bitter partisanship and petty bickering that's shut you out, let you down and told you to settle. We know our road will not be easy. …………………..

Hope is not blind optimism. I know how hard it will be to make these changes. I know this because I fought on the streets of Chicago as a community organizer to bring jobs to the jobless in the shadow of a shuttered steel plant. I've fought in the courts as a civil rights lawyer to make sure people weren't denied their rights because of what they looked like or where they came from. I've fought in the legislature to take power away from lobbyists. I've won some of those fights, but I've lost some of them too. I've seen good legislation die because good intentions weren't backed by a mandate for change.

The politics of hope does not mean hoping things come easy. Because nothing worthwhile in this country has ever happened unless somebody, somewhere stood up when it was hard; stood up when they were told – no you can't, and said yes we can.

So, I'm not going to wait around for an ineffective party leadership to do the right thing, I'm going to act out what I believe. It's risky - but - it's also the very reason I've supported Obama, because he understands that we have to stand up together and demand change.

So, on Monday, I'm going to call a few people and demand a little change. And just maybe if enough people decide to do the same thing the impossible will happen and we'll get a little change.

{"commentId":1555766,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#2.3 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 4:05 PM EST
{"commentId":1556034,"authorDomain":"wharrison55"}

Well, what is your solution to the problem? It would seem to me the main issues involve who would pay for a revote in MI and FL? The party? The states? The candidates?

{"commentId":1556034,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"wharrison55"}
  • 1 vote
#2.4 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 5:54 PM EST
{"commentId":1556129,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

My solution to the problem is in this article. Personally, I have no power to sit all parties down and work out solutions to the questions you ask. But:

1. I can pick up a telephone and make a few phone calls.
2. I can ask others to do the same.
3. I can keep trying to get through. If the phone calls turn into voice systems, I can search for new phone numbers... I can keep reaching out to other people and hope that they can help me find phone numbers of organizations and people who should be calling the Carter Center.

Yes I - no WE - can :)

I know that sounds corny - but all the Obama supporters have been chanting "Yes we can" for months now. It's time to put up, or shut up. Obama has always said that change would not come easy, that we would have to work for change. Well now the work is upon us, and we are capable of making a difference.

{"commentId":1556129,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#2.5 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 6:23 PM EST
{"commentId":1566596,"authorDomain":"DrKnow"}

The DNC did not create the problem. The people in the states did. They knew the rules and made a conscious decision to violate them. They "did not care." Why did they "not care"? Maybe because they count on this happening? They should not be rewarded for opposing the rules intentionally.

{"commentId":1566596,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"DrKnow"}
  • 1 vote
#2.6 - Tue Mar 11, 2008 6:53 PM EDT
{"commentId":1566679,"authorDomain":"roybatty"}
They should not be rewarded for opposing the rules intentionally.

Absolutely.

However, there is no DNC rule that states that valid primaries or caucuses can't still be held in Florida or Michigan. Maybe the Democratic Committees in those states should be fund raising to pay for a proper apportioning of delegates? Instead of whining about it?

Otherwise, the DNC rules prevail.

{"commentId":1566679,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"roybatty"}
  • 1 vote
#2.7 - Tue Mar 11, 2008 7:14 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1555153,"authorDomain":"O-K"}

There is no good solution for this and it will not matter very much. The race is close and even adding Florida and Michigan would change little. Redoing them would change little. The superdelegates will decide this so the best idea would be forget about it and let the democratic convention decide.

{"commentId":1555153,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"O-K"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#3 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 1:00 PM EST
{"commentId":1555225,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

O-K - you're right - there is no good solution. That I agree with. And it will be decided by the super delegates - you are right.

I'm not doing this because I think that it will make a difference in the final numbers. I'm doing this because I'm fed up with living in a country where our elections discount votes.

When the DNC made those rules (and FL and MI voted on them) no one thought it would matter. Everyone thought the decision would be made by super Tuesday. And now we're in a situation where (once again) the average voter had no say so in the matter and their votes don't count.

I've been following the discussion about voter fraud in OH.

Before the TX primary/caucus it came out that the Clinton campaign was coaching their constituents on how to take control of the caucus' ...

We all remember how Al Gore's campaign ended.....

I'm just fed up with living in a country that the rest of the world looks to as a model for democracy and we can't even run an election in a fair and balanced way.

Besides all of that - study the 1968 Democratic Convention (here)

Between the super delegates, FL and MI the democrats are setting themselves up for a horrid convention and turning this whole election over to the republicans. We (as a party) need to solve these problems now, before the convention.

I make no pretense of being neutral. There are very few neutral people this year. That is why we need the Carter Center.

{"commentId":1555225,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 2 votes
#3.1 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 1:19 PM EST
Reply
{"commentId":1555870,"authorDomain":"O-K"}

I am neutral, or I'm against all three still running, Obama, Clinton, McCain. I'm not sure if this mess can be straightened out but I do think the Carter Center would be one of the best to try. It could not hurt. I'm not ma democrat-or republican- so I have no vested interest in who wins. But for a democrat I can see that a quick resolution to the nomination contest would help the party in November.

{"commentId":1555870,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"O-K"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#4 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 4:48 PM EST
{"commentId":1556016,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
I'm not sure if this mess can be straightened out but I do think the Carter Center would be one of the best to try

Precisely :)

The Carter Center is known throughout the world for its ability to help mediate resolutions to conflict and for its ability to find fair election solutions. President Carter has the stature (within the Democratic Party) and is capable of acting in a neutral and fair fashion. It amazes me that the 3rd world countries can make use of the Carter Center's assistance, but the leaders of our own Democratic party seem completely oblivious to the Carter Center's existence, or its ability to help find fair and honorable solutions.

{"commentId":1556016,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#5 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 5:46 PM EST
{"commentId":1556582,"authorDomain":"tbh29520"}

It is my opinion that it was the governors of both states that made the bad decisions! They were anxious to have their states participate earlier than scheduled. Therefore they took it upon themselves to moved up their dates. They were told of the consequences and said whatever....Michigan should have known there would be a problem when only one democratic candidate was on the ballot. They did not care! The people were told it would not count and so many did not vote. In Florida, only Clinton showed up for a Town meeting. I believe they both had advertising that overlapped in the area, but no paid advertising was done for either location. Florida's governor himself said he wasn't going to listen to the DNC and there are always ways to get around things! His angle from the start was to cause disaray in the democratic party. He endorsed John McCain prior to the Florida election. My point is that both states knew the rules and broke the rules. They were told of the consequences. The people of the state may be upset because they were told their votes would not count, therefore they were not given the chance to vote. I know some did vote, but the majority did not vote! I don't think the people are concerned about who gets seated at the DNC. I think the states should sponsor and pay for their own elections! Maybe next time they will play by the rules. If they get away with it this time, other states will try the same thing next election season......Discipline is the best choice!

{"commentId":1556582,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"tbh29520"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#6 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 8:56 PM EST
{"commentId":1556809,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
Florida's governor himself said he wasn't going to listen to the DNC and there are always ways to get around things! His angle from the start was to cause disaray in the democratic party.

Raven - I can see both sides of the issue. As you said, the governors made the decision. One of them was republican and has a vested interested in throwing the democratic party into chaos. Bottom line - the average voter probably had no say-so in it what-so-ever.

It was idiotic to set the rules up the way they were set up in the first place. There are a lot of ways to penalize states that break rules without taking the vote away from an entire constituency.

I don't have any good ideas for a resolution. But, common sense tells me that if the DNC, FL, MI and the two campaigns (Clinton and Obama) don't come to some reasonable solution the convention is going to be a mess. Also, the DNC will risk loosing MI and FL as well. If I were an average citizen in those states and the DNC leadership and governor took my vote away from me, I'd be very, very, very angry.

And the fact that the Florida governor said he wasn't going to listen to the DNC is ample evidence of election tampering. That alone is reason to call in the Carter Center - because if there is a do-over - the last thing anyone needs is the Governor of FL tampering with the process.

(Just my thoughts on the subject)

{"commentId":1556809,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#6.1 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 10:23 PM EST
{"commentId":1557009,"authorDomain":"tbh29520"}

I agree with your thoughts on the Carter Center. If there is another election, it definetly needs to be monitored by outsiders.

The people in the states need to be mad. They need to be telling their elected officials of their concerns. They should have done this before the elections were held. Both states voted on the rules of the DNC and then chose to not abide by the rules. This is why I think that the DNC should not have to pay and that the states should pay! The DNC did not break the rules, the states did! The DNC is only trying to enforce the rules. If they don't enforce the rules what do you think will happen next election season, the same or worse? Disciplinary action must be in enforced. Penalties must be paid. Perhaps the DNC could pay with exchange for 5th degree felony charges being brought towards both governors for voting tampering!

Just my opinion...justice must start somewhere...

{"commentId":1557009,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"tbh29520"}
  • 2 votes
#6.2 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 11:52 PM EST
Reply
{"commentId":1556967,"authorDomain":"jcrusin"}

Here's my solution that allows them representation but does not reward them for not following the rules like the other states did. Divide their delegates straight down the middle for each candidate-50% each. This formula doesn't allow them to influence or change the race but stops the main argument they are running with that their states should be represented. Let's seat them this way and be done with this discussion.

{"commentId":1556967,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"jcrusin"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#7 - Sat Mar 8, 2008 11:32 PM EST
{"commentId":1557041,"authorDomain":"tbh29520"}

That would make the delegates happy. They could attend the Party! What about the people of the state that did not get a chance to vote because they were told their vote would not count? Why should several people be awarded at the expense of millions? I would think it would be more constitutional for the peoples rights to vote over who attends a party!

{"commentId":1557041,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"tbh29520"}
  • 2 votes
#7.1 - Sun Mar 9, 2008 12:04 AM EST
{"commentId":1557462,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Both of you have valid points. But.... bottom line ... we could discuss possible solutions until the end of time and it wouldn't change the facts on the ground.

The only thing we can do that MIGHT change the facts on the ground, that MIGHT make a difference, is to work together. WE can work together to draft the Carter Center. It won't be easy. Chances are the phone numbers listed above will lead to never-ending voice mail systems. So... we are going to have to work together.

If enough of us work together we might be able to find more phone numbers, more email addresses to the organizations who can invite the Carter Center in. But... we have to DO it TOGETHER.

We have to use today to get the word out and invite everyone we can think of into the draft process.

The ONLY HONEST chance for a fair solution here is the Carter Center.

They have a sterling reputation for their work in this area - I don't know any other organization that could come in and help find solutions and be trusted by all sides.

So... I am asking with humbleness (because I know it's a long-shot) but ... please consider
1. Spending some time today on your computer, hunting down phone numbers and such that we can call.

2. Spending time today hunting down email addresses of people that can call in the Carter Center - or can get the word out to their membership to help the draft process. (For instance: I've been trying to find legitimate contact information for MoveON. Their contact list is fantastic. One email to their contact list - from their leadership to act would make a REAL difference in this draft attempt.)

3. Post them here .... I'll grab them and put them into the main article (so people can see them at the top).

4. Email links to this article to as many people as you can think, your friends and family in the "real" world and your friends on this board.

Let's make an honest effort to see if we can get this draft process off the ground. If we fail, at least we've tried. If we don't fail - there may actually be a little bit of change in our world - that we can feel a part of. .....

{"commentId":1557462,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#7.2 - Sun Mar 9, 2008 7:32 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1560774,"authorDomain":"gmarez"}

Seems to me like the citizens of PA ought to be upset that their governor is willing to help raise funds for primaries in two other states when his own suffers from financial problems.

If I lived in PA, I'd be verrry unhappy and let him know. Corzine sure has a lot of gaul.

{"commentId":1560774,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"gmarez"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#8 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 9:55 AM EDT
{"commentId":1560802,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

OK - folks - I just called the campaign headquarters of Obama (866) 675-2008. I actually got to speak to a live person. It didn't take me more than 10 minutes from dialing the phone, to talking with the volunteer, to hanging up.

If enough of us call - this idea will float to the surface at his national headquarters. And we can stop the Clinton campaign from controlling this issue by involving a neutral party like the Carter Center.

Please consider getting involved - just pick up the phone and call the Obama headquarters.

Marez:

"If I lived in PA, I'd be verrry unhappy and let him know. Corzine sure has a lot of gaul."

I don't live in PA and I'm upset. Clinton is pushing this in the media and she will get her way - but we can do something about it. Just take a few minutes. Call the Obama headquarters, then email your friends and ask them to do the same. We can do this - we are the change we've been waiting for.

{"commentId":1560802,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#9 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 10:03 AM EDT
{"commentId":1561524,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

I just called the DNC and Nancy Polosi's office and got through to humans in both offices. It took me all of 10 minutes for both phone calls. I just told the person answering the phone to pass my message along and that inviting the Carter Center in to mediate a resolution and monitor any revote is something EVERY democrat could get behind. The phone numbers are in the original article - please just take a few moments and make 1 or 2 calls. Then email your friends and ask them to do the same.

The phone numbers you should concentrate on are:

1. Obama's campaign headquarters: (866) 675-2008
2. DNC: (202) 863-8000
3. Pelosi's office: (202) 225-4965

{"commentId":1561524,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#10 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 1:30 PM EDT
{"commentId":1562521,"authorDomain":"shoparoo"}

I just called Obama's campaign and the Democratic Party. I talked to a live body both places. Obama's campaign sounded like they were actually taking notes and were very receptive. Democratic Party didn't ask my name, or anything else. I think they didn't want to be bothered. I think that perhaps this idea needs to be sent to other news sources to gain any strength. Just an FYI, I don't have a problem with no do-over in my state of MI. I agree that the rules were broken and there are and should be consequences. But, if there is going to be a do-over I want it to be impartial and fair.

{"commentId":1562521,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"shoparoo"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#11 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 5:30 PM EDT
{"commentId":1562573,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Penny - Thank you for posting a comment about your reception. Also - if you can get me the phone numbers to different news organizations - I'll post them in the lead article.

If we all pitch in - we can make a difference here.

Thanks:

Pavilion

{"commentId":1562573,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#11.1 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 5:45 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1562815,"authorDomain":"fhegel3"}

The decision to break the rules here in Michigan was made by the 80 member Michigan Democratic Party Central Committee (MDPCC). The vote was 79-1. There was no request for input from either voters or members of the Michigan Democratic Party (MDP). Many of the Central Committee members are not directly elected to that office, but are there by virtue of holding some other office, much like the super delegates, which in fact they are. A large number of them are declared supporters of Senator Clinton, and many of the rest have a history of supporting her. Such is the nature of the undemocratic nature of the Democratic party. This is precisely why the party has stagnated. The back rooms may no longer be smoke filled, but they are most certainly filled with good ol' backslapping boys and girls who have little regard for the opinions of the working class of America. In all fairness, I must cut the Central Committee some slack here, in that they made this decision when many observers considered Senator Clinton to be the presumtive nominee. But I cut them no slack whatsoever when some of them state that this was a fair and legal primary. It was NOT and they have created a mess that does great harm to the party and the democratic process.

{"commentId":1562815,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"fhegel3"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#12 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 7:04 PM EDT
{"commentId":1562916,"authorDomain":"fhegel3"}

The only solution that will be acceptable to the voters of Michigan would include a real contest with a real vote. That may be a hard sell to the various parties with a vested interest.

My personal choice is the "firehouse vote" option, so long as it includes an absentee provision. That is the least expensive and could be put together fairly fast. I think many venues could be had for free or just cleanup charges. The polling would be run by the same folks, using the same equipment as a regular primary.

Under the present party rules and state laws, there is no way to prevent new crossovers, but those who voted in the Republican primary should be excluded.

{"commentId":1562916,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"fhegel3"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#13 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 7:41 PM EDT
{"commentId":1563400,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
The only solution that will be acceptable to the voters of Michigan would include a real contest with a real vote. That may be a hard sell to the various parties with a vested interest.

Hello UncleFreddy:

The best chance of getting a fair vote is to invite the Carter Center into the process. I hope you'll consider making a few phone calls. Also, email a link to this article to all your friends in MI - ask them to make some phone calls as well.

{"commentId":1563400,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#13.1 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 10:21 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1563563,"authorDomain":"suekzoo"}

I called the Obama campaign headquarters, and they seemed very interested in this idea. The volunteer I spoke with mentioned receiving other calls. I took that as a good sign. I also called the DNC, and the result was not as positive. The woman who I spoke to said that the campaigns and state parties needed to work out the details within the rules. I also tried to reach Nancy Pelosi's office, but got voice mail. I will continue to call her this week.

I strong advocate making the calls. Momentum is developing to have a re-vote. It must be fair and transparent, and monitored by a neutral party would be ideal.

{"commentId":1563563,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"suekzoo"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#14 - Mon Mar 10, 2008 11:15 PM EDT
{"commentId":1564925,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Thanks suekzoo - This effort is getting a lot of help from some Obama listserves in MI and FL. People are making the phone calls. And consistently they're saying that the Obama campaign answers the phone and responds respectfully.

The fact that the DNC is polite, but non-responsive, is all the more reason to pursue inviting the Carter Center in. You are right

Momentum is developing to have a re-vote. It must be fair and transparent, and monitored by a neutral party would be ideal.

We can't count on the DNC, the Republicans in control of FL or the Clinton supporters pushing for this to be fair. A neutral party has to be involved, and if "we the people" invite them in, we stand a good chance of it succeeding. I'd like to see the DNC and the Clinton camp say "no" to former president Carter and the Carter Center. They are our best hope for fairness on the ground. Please - everyone - just take 10 minutes today and make some phone calls (especially to the Obama campaign, the DNC offices and the Pelosi office).

After you've called, come back and let us know how it went for you. Who you reached, what they said.

And lastly, email all your friends. Forward a link to this article and ask them to get involved.

{"commentId":1564925,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#14.1 - Tue Mar 11, 2008 11:09 AM EDT
{"commentId":1570086,"authorDomain":"DrKnow"}

Why does the DNC have to negotiate? They made the rules with the input of everyone. The people in those states knew the rules and intentionally violated them. What is there to negotiate? Any concession they get sets the precedent that the "rules" are not rules but imaginary guidelines.

{"commentId":1570086,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"DrKnow"}
  • 1 vote
#14.2 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 3:23 PM EDT
{"commentId":1570162,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

You know, Dr Know - on a personal level I don't care if there is ever a revote. This whole mess sucks. It's been a screw up from start to finish.

I care about one thing - a solution that is fair and honest. We can sit on these discussion boards and debate until the end of time about what should have been done, what should be done, etc.. and none of our debating will ensure a fair and honest solution to a problem that the media is controlling (and forcing a re-vote).

So... instead of sitting around grousing and groaning about the problem, I'm actually doing something to try and get a sane voice in the whole process. And - maybe with a little sanity will come a solution you want - we do nothing - we let the rules stand as they are. I don't know.

What I do know - is that if I sit here and do nothing - the media and power brokers will do what they always do - they'll push the most sensational solution even though it's not the best or the honest solution.

Jimmy Carter and the Carter Center may be the one hope we have for a sane solution - and I'm going for it.

And as far as your question, "Why does the DNC have to negotiate? They made the rules with the input of everyone."....

Last I saw, Howard Dean - head of the DNC - came out and said he'd support a mail-in vote. Who do you suppose we can trust to count those votes? Who are you going to trust to make sure people don't vote twice, or that everyone who is entitled to vote gets to vote? Are you going to trust the FL republicans with that??????

{"commentId":1570162,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#14.3 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 3:42 PM EDT
{"commentId":1570245,"authorDomain":"roybatty"}

Did you know that Jimmy Carter is a superdelegate?

As such, he has a decision to make. Could his predilection for one candidate or another directly or indirectly effect efforts made by the Carter Center?

{"commentId":1570245,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"roybatty"}
  • 2 votes
#14.4 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 3:59 PM EDT
{"commentId":1570371,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Excellent question. Do you know if he's made a public declaration for either candidate yet?

I think if he's remained neutral thus far, I'd want to pursue this.

What needs to happen - and Howard Dean isn't going to do it - Nancy Pelosi tried - is for someone to sit down in a room with both Clinton and Obama and get to the core of what's going on here. (Memories of Jimmy Carter running between two cabins at Camp David to get a sign onto the Camp David accord - come to mind)

I can see Obama agreeing to sit down and get to the core of what's happening here. He has already said publicly that Dean should be doing more to mediate a resolution.

So - bottom line - if Carter has not declared one way or the other - he may be the one person (a former president and a back ground in mediation) to work towards a solution that is fair and viable.

Please understand - my efforts here are not intended to be seen as supporting a re-vote. I just simply see what's being played out by the power brokers - and if it comes to that - I want it done honestly and fairly.

{"commentId":1570371,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#14.5 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 4:26 PM EDT
{"commentId":1570428,"authorDomain":"roybatty"}
Please understand - my efforts here are not intended to be seen as supporting a re-vote. I just simply see what's being played out by the power brokers - and if it comes to that - I want it done honestly and fairly.

I agree, I think we all want that.

I did not see Jimmy Carter's name on the superdelegate endorsement list, so I assume he has not yet endorsed. BTW, here's the entire Democratic superdelagtes list.

{"commentId":1570428,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"roybatty"}
  • 2 votes
#14.6 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 4:37 PM EDT
{"commentId":1571572,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
I agree, I think we all want that.

Yes - I think we do....

The one chance for fairness here is the Carter Center and Jimmy Carter. If you can do anything at all to help - I'd appreciate it. Email your friends - ask them to make some phone calls. Go to MoveOn.org, find their suggestion page and email them. Write Moveon.org and tell them we need their help to get the Carter Center involved, that this election is being stolen right under our noses. They have the membership to bring national attention to what's happening.

Read this article , it's happening as we sleep tonight. The FL party bosses want this nailed down fast.

Oh - and the more you comment and vote on this article the better the chances of moving it "up the vine" so that others can see and act on it. Thanks.

{"commentId":1571572,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 1 vote
#14.7 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 10:48 PM EDT
{"commentId":1571987,"authorDomain":"roybatty"}
Oh - and the more you comment and vote on this article the better the chances of moving it "up the vine" so that others can see and act on it. Thanks

You read this, read it again. This is important. Vote!

{"commentId":1571987,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"roybatty"}
  • 2 votes
#14.8 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 2:11 AM EDT
{"commentId":1572107,"authorDomain":"DrKnow"}

We "all" do not want a solution. The party bosses in the two states chose to violate the rules. Let them fully suffer the consequences. The party members in those states knew that the rules were being violated and chose to smugly go along with the party bosses. If the rank and file had said something, this would not have happened. Now they want to say "Oops, our bad" and get a do over. It should NOT happen.

{"commentId":1572107,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"DrKnow"}
  • 2 votes
#14.9 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 4:09 AM EDT
{"commentId":1572122,"authorDomain":"roybatty"}

Dr Know, I agree with you completely. And my assumption is that the Carter Commission (or whatever it will be called) will come to the same conclusion. The DNC has set rules, they were ratified, FL and MI decided to break them, now they must deal with the consequences.

I see this as a way to validate and support to the current rules, not to circumvent them.

Then again, being human, I'm not always right.

{"commentId":1572122,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"roybatty"}
  • 2 votes
#14.10 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 4:24 AM EDT
{"commentId":1575120,"authorDomain":"DrKnow"}

I have another question. This is a problem for the people in two states. Why does everyone think it is their business to "fix" it? It is the sole business of the people in the states that clearly knew the rules, broke them, got a "ticket" and now everyone else wants the 'ticket' to be 'fixed'.

It is a wonder that anyone obeys any laws. Do we get to pick and choose which rules apply to us?

{"commentId":1575120,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"DrKnow"}
  • 1 vote
#14.11 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 7:58 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1567984,"authorDomain":"FreeRadical"}

This is an excellent suggestion and I fully support it. Thanks for the post.

{"commentId":1567984,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"FreeRadical"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#15 - Wed Mar 12, 2008 2:30 AM EDT
{"commentId":1574158,"authorDomain":"ecom4all"}

Thanks for the suggestion. Using your numbers I phoned the Carter Center, the DNC, the Obama Campaign, and the Clinton Campaign. I am waiting to hear back from the Carter Center. The Obama campaign wrote down my suggestions, thanked me, and mentioned that a few others had called as well. The DNC assistant to the Chairman thought it was a good idea and promised to pass it on to Howard Dean. The Clinton campaign was voice-menu driven. Nobody seems to be manning the ship and all voice-mail boxes were full except for Maggie Smith. When I pushed her number, I got Mark Penn's recording and a new number to call. I called that number and got someone named Bobby who was not at headquarters, but in a meeting. I quickly gave him the suggestion, but I'm not sure where it is going to end up. Hope someone else has better luck.

{"commentId":1574158,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"ecom4all"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#16 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 3:02 PM EDT
{"commentId":1575581,"authorDomain":"1stcontact"}

Hello Everyone:

Thank you for making phone calls, sending emails and contributing to this article with your comments. In addition to all the public comments - there have been private communications as well. What I'd like to say here - is that some things may unfold within the next few days. So, I'm going to ask all of you (who have been working so hard and been so enthusiastic about the Carter Center option) to stand down for a bit. At this point I believe, very deeply, that we need to take a wait and see attitude.

I know this must be coming out of left-field for you - but I'm going to ask you to trust what I am saying. I didn't start this whole thing easily. It is not in my character to get this deeply involved in politics, but something just kept at me about this situation and so I took action, when I never have before. I really want to thank all of you who have made phone calls, sent emails, and gotten involved in this effort. Your time has not been wasted. We worked together and lived up to Barack Obama's expectations of us:

I'm asking you to believe, not just in my ability to bring about real change in Washington ... I'm asking you to believe in yours.

We believed in our ability, and I honestly feel it made a difference. Thank you all for everything you have done and for all of your enthusiasm.

To summarize: There are some things that may unfold within the next few days. So, I'm going to ask all of you to stand down from pursuing the Carter Center option for a bit. At this point I believe, very deeply, that we need to take a wait and see attitude.

In Peace:

Pavilion

{"commentId":1575581,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"1stcontact"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#17 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 10:38 PM EDT
{"commentId":1575687,"authorDomain":"DrKnow"}

I hope that NOTHING happens. Anything would simply demonstrate that you can never believe anything either political party says are "rules".

{"commentId":1575687,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"DrKnow"}
  • 3 votes
#17.1 - Thu Mar 13, 2008 11:25 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":1579500,"authorDomain":"O-K"}

It now looks like Michigan will have a primary in June; Florida is still undecided.

{"commentId":1579500,"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290","authorDomain":"O-K"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#18 - Fri Mar 14, 2008 8:52 PM EDT
{"canLink":false,"threadId":"231462","isPrivate":false}
Leave a Comment:
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
{"threadId":"231462","contentId":"1352290"}
Start TrackingStart Tracking
Stop TrackingStop Tracking